Skip to main content
Phone ScamsHigh Risk

Fake Toll Calls: Spotting Unpaid Toll Scam Phone Calls

A phone caller claims you have unpaid tolls and must pay immediately by card, gift card, or a link they dictate. Hang up. Check your official toll account yourself, do not pay a surprise caller.

November 10, 2026 · 3 min read · Updated November 10, 2026

Photo: Pexels

What happened?

Your phone rings. The caller says you owe SunPass, E ZPass, FasTrak, or another toll balance. They may spoof a local or “toll authority” number. They demand payment by card over the phone, a gift card, a wire, or a link they text after the call, and they warn of late fees, registration holds, or police involvement if you delay.

**Direct answer:** Hang up. Do not pay a surprise toll caller. Open your real toll account on the official website or app you already trust, or call the agency using a number from that site, not from the inbound call.

That pattern is a phone based unpaid toll scam (related to text/smishing toll scams, but the first contact is a call). Imposters use familiar program names and urgency so you share a card number or one time code before you can verify. Treat unexpected payment demands the same whether they arrive by call or text.

You are not careless for wanting to clear a toll. Cashless roads make surprise balances feel plausible. Pause, verify on an official channel, and call or text SAM at 844-8-ASK-SAM before you pay anyone who called you.

Who is being targeted?

Drivers who use electronic toll programs and answer unfamiliar numbers.

Travelers who recently drove in another state and are unsure about a toll charge.

Older adults who prefer phone calls over apps and may read a card number aloud when pressured.

Caregivers who manage a parent’s phone should agree not to pay toll claims from inbound calls.

How the scam works

  1. 1You receive an unexpected call claiming unpaid tolls or a suspended tag account.
  2. 2The caller uses a familiar program name and may spoof caller ID.
  3. 3They demand immediate payment by card, gift card, wire, crypto, or a link they send.
  4. 4Any card numbers or codes you share are used for theft; some victims also install remote access apps.
  5. 5The caller disappears; the real toll agency never placed that collection call.

Warning signs

⚠ Surprise calls demanding toll payment within minutes

⚠ Payment by gift card, wire, crypto, or a link that arrived only from the caller

⚠ Threats of tow, arrest, or license suspension if you do not pay during the call

⚠ Refusal to let you hang up and call the official number on the agency’s website

⚠ Requests for remote access to “fix” your toll account on your computer or phone

⚠ Caller ID that looks official but does not match the number published on the real toll site

What you should do

  • ✓Hang up. Do not read card numbers or one time codes to a surprise toll caller.
  • ✓Check balances only inside the official toll website or app you look up yourself.
  • ✓Prefer official account auto pay settings over phone payments to strangers.
  • ✓If a caregiver helps with driving accounts, decide together that inbound toll collection calls are a hang up.
  • ✓Report the call at reportfraud.ftc.gov.
  • ✓Call or text SAM at 844-8-ASK-SAM to check the story before you pay, scam check help, not a guarantee.
  • ✓Report it to the FTC with our free step by step guide: how to report a scam to the FTC. A report helps investigators spot patterns, but it doesn't guarantee an investigation or getting money back.

Already responded?

If you already interacted with the scammer, act quickly — the sooner you move, the more you can protect.

  • !Contact your bank or card issuer immediately about charges or shared card details.
  • !If you installed remote access software, disconnect, uninstall it, and change passwords from a clean device.
  • !Save the caller’s number and any payment references for reports.
  • !Report at reportfraud.ftc.gov and consider filing with ic3.gov.
  • !Call or text SAM at 844-8-ASK-SAM for next step questions while you work with your bank.

Ask SAM

Still not sure?

Call or message SAM before taking any action. Your first 2 scam checks are free, and SAM is private and available 24/7.

Trusted sources

Risk level: High Risk. Risk levels are set by the SilverSafe editorial team based on how quickly this scam moves money and how often it succeeds.
Related scams

Keep learning.

Phone ScamsHigh Risk

Fake Bank Fraud Department Calls Draining Accounts

Hang up and call the number on your card, do not move money to a “safe” account or hand cash to a courier. A caller claiming to be from your bank’s fraud team tries to scare you into moving money or sharing account details. Hang up, call the number printed on your own card or app, and never move funds to a “safe account” on a stranger’s instructions.

Published November 1, 2025 · Updated November 9, 2026 · 5 min read

Phone ScamsCritical Risk

Grandparent Scam Cash Couriers: Verify Before Anyone Arrives

Never hand cash to a courier after a grandchild in trouble call, hang up and verify on a known number. A panic call claims a grandchild needs bail, then a courier or driver may arrive for cash. FBI IC3 and federal cases describe this courier pattern. Never hand money to someone at your door based on a phone call alone, verify with family first.

Published March 10, 2025 · Updated November 9, 2026 · 3 min read

Phone ScamsHigh Risk

Grandma, I'm in Jail, San Diego Seniors Share How Scammers Tried to Steal Their Money

Hang up and call your grandchild on a known number, use a family safe word before any money moves. At a San Ysidro senior center, grandparents described calls that sounded like a grandchild in jail, stuck at an airport, or in trouble in Mexico. Hang up, verify with family on a number you already know, and never send money from the panic call alone.

Published January 20, 2025 · Updated November 9, 2026 · 3 min read

Newsletter

Get your free Family Scam Defense Kit

Learn the warning signs, set up a family safe word, and keep a checklist for what to do if a scam happens.

Read our scam alerts

Enter your email to get the kit and Ask SAM Weekly—free, practical scam alerts once a week. Unsubscribe anytime.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe with one click. Privacy policy